Measuring and evaluating the status of urban vitality components from the perspective of citizens (Case Study: Urmia City)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

• robab hoseinzadeh ¹
• esmaiel safaralizadeh ²

¹ Assistant Professor of Geography & Urban Planning, PNU University, Tehran, Iran

² Assistant Professor of Urban Geography, PNU University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Nowadays, cities as living things require vitality and vitality. Creating and enhancing vitality in an urban environment requires the coherence of space characteristics to meet the needs of citizens, which in turn can lead to an increase in continuous presence and quality of life. This research carried out with the aim of measuring and evaluating urban vitality indicators in Urmia. The statistical population of the study consisted of citizens of five regions of Urmia city and the sample size in this study was 383 people. Sampling method was random sampling. This research is a survey based on purpose, applied and based on the research strategy, and a questionnaire has been use to collect data. Validity of the questionnaire obtained by content validity and its reliability through Cronbach's alpha (0.785). For data analysis, multivariate regression, single-sample T-test and Kruskal test with using SPSS software. The results of the research show that there is a significant relationship between the socio-economic status of citizens and the urban vitality rate in Urmia using the components of education and residence time in the region. Other findings showed that among the studied components, social dimension with the highest mean (3.01) had the highest rank and then the spatial dimension (2.53) was second, economic dimension (2.14) was in the third place and in the second place the final experimental side (2.10) is in fourth place. Finally, it concluded that the distribution of urban vitality components has been unfair in terms of citizens.
Extended Abstract:
Introduction:
     Today, successful cities are cities that are develop in accordance with the values, norms and desires of its inhabitants and provide creative, dynamic and vibrant spaces for their attendees. Conceptual vivacity is defined as urban space and is defined in both the micro and macro levels; in the macro level, in addition to the vivacity of the urban space, concepts such as fairness, efficiency, efficiency, efficiency ultimately; the vibrancy of the city will lead to vulnerability if sustained. Meanwhile, the city of Urmia as the capital of West Azerbaijan province and one of the settler cities, disrupting the balance between population and facilities, fails to create a sense of place and, consequently, in the absence of vibrant communal spaces, the spread of social injustice. Giving physical identity has declined. Considering the importance and necessity of this topic, this research is trying to analyze the components of urban vitality in Urmia. To this end, the present Study seeks to answer the following questions:
1- What is the relationship between the socio-economic base of citizens and the rate of life in Urmia?
2- What is the status of the components of Urmia's urban vitality from the citizens' point of view?
Methodology:
       The research method is descriptive-analytical and based on documentary studies, libraries and field studies. In the present study, the evaluation of the status of the components of the vitality of the city of Urmia from the citizens' point of view, using a survey method and distribution of a researcher-made questionnaire, using Likert spectrum. The validity of the scale measured by the opinions of 12 teachers, experts, and experts in the field of content validity. The reliability of the questionnaire was calculated by Cronbach's alpha method and its coefficient was 0.785, which indicates the reliability of this questionnaire. In the process of questioning with the knowledge that the statistical population of the study was 705805 people in 1395, the sample size, based on Cochran formula, with 95% significance level, 383 people and sampling method used. It is a coincidence. Multivariate regression, one-sample t-test and Kruskal-Wallis test used for data analysis and SPSS software.
Results and discussion:
       In order to evaluate the status of urban vitality indicators in Urmia city based on Cochran method, 383 people interviewed. One sample T-test used to examine urban vitality from the viewpoint of the citizens of Urmia. Given that the Likert spectrum (1 to 5) is used to answer the questionnaire questions, the average limit is therefore three, so if the mean is higher than three are, it indicates high vitality and if Lower than three indicates lower vitality. Thirteen items used to examine the economic dimension. T-test results show that most of the items gained less than average weight. 14 items were used to examine the spatial index of vitality. Most of the items under study have lower than average averages. With the exception of items 8 and 9, which are above average, however, items 8 have a significant level above 0.05, which is not statistically significant and cannot be compared to the whole city area. Gave.15 items were used to assess the social vitality index. According to the results of the single-sample T-test, it can be said that half of the items gained a weighted average grade point average and higher. Overall, a single-sample T-test for the spatial index (2.53) shows that residents do not rate the city space at an optimal level. To test the empirical index of vitality, 13 items were used. The results of T-test showed that none of the studied items gained above average weight. From the citizens' point of view, the empirical dimension index is below average (2.10) and is not rated as favorable. In general, it can be said that the distribution of vitality indicators across the city of Urmia was uneven. Is. According to the average vitality index in Urmia city, social dimension has the highest rank (3.01), followed by spatial dimension (2.53), second, economic dimension (14.14, respectively). 2) In the third place and finally in the experimental dimension (2/10) is in the fourth place.
Conclusion:
      Urban vitality is a concept of urban space and can be defined at both micro and macro levels; at the macro level, in addition to the vitality of urban spaces, concepts such as justice, efficiency, adaptability, flexibility, environmental quality are also included. It takes over. The purpose of this study was to evaluate and evaluate the components of Urmia city's vitality from the citizens' point of view. Four economic, social, spatial and empirical components were employed. The amount of explanation showed that the socio-economic base of the inhabitants of the city influences 0.769% of the changes and increase in the level of urban vitality (in economic, social, spatial and empirical dimensions). The results of the evaluation of the components of urban vitality showed that the social dimension with the mean (3.01) was the highest and then the spatial dimension (2.53) in the second place, economic dimension (2.14) in the third place respectively. Finally, the experimental dimension (2/10) ranks fourth. Regarding the frequency and results of the tests, it can be concluded that urban life in Urmia has a significant relationship with the increase of education, household income, housing ownership and ultimately with the improvement of socio-economic status.

Keywords

• Urban space
• Liveliness and vitality
• urban vitality
• Quality of life
• Urmia city

20.1001.1.22285229.1399.11.42.11.2

---

References

-          Akhavan, A. Salehi, I. Toghani, S. (2018):  Assessing the Impact of Environmental - Physical Factors on the Vitality and Quality of Urban Streets (Case Study: Rare and Revolutionary Streets of Sari City), Geography and Sustainability, Volume 8, Number 2, pp. 29-15

-          Appleyard, D. (1981): Livable streets, Berkeley, CA, University of California press.

-          Appleyard, D., and M. Lintell (1972) the Environmental Quality of City Streets: The Residents Viewpoint, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 38(2), pp. 84-101.

-          Bosselmann, P., Macdonald, E., Kronemeyer, T. (1999): Livable streets revisited, Journal of the American Planning Association, 65 (2), pp. 168-180.

-          Cowan, Robert (2005): The dictionary of urbanism illustrated by Lucinda Rogers, preface by sir peter hall, streetwise.

-          Cullen G. (2013): The concise townscape, (M. tabibian, Trans). Tehran university publication

-          Gehl, J. (1987): Life between Buildings, Van Nostrand Reinhold press.

-          Jacobs, J. (2002): The Death and Life of Great American Cities. The Modern Library, New York.

-          Golkar, K. (2007): Concept of vitality in urban design, Journal of Safeh, No. 44, pp. 66-75.

-          Habibi, K., Nastaran, M., Mohammadi, M. (2016): Evaluation and Evaluation of Urban Public Spaces Vitality and its Role in Improving the Quality of Life of Cognitive Youth: East Nazar Street of Isfahan, Geography and Urban-Regional Design, No. 19, Summer 2016, pp. 180-161

-          Hosseini Mofrad, M.H., Dolaii, P. (2013): Investigating the Factors Affecting the Increased Sense of Market Live ness (Case Study of Bandar Abbas Old Market) ,Conference on Architecture and Urban Development and Sustainable Development, Khavaran Institute of Higher Education.

-          Iran Statistical Center (2016): Latest Results of the General Census of Population and Housing.

-          Jacobs, J. (2009): "The Death of the Great American Cities", Translated by Hamid Reza, Plato, Wish, Tehran University Press & Publishing, First Edition, No. 554.

-          Jacobs, A., Appleyard, D. (1987): Toward an Urban Design Manifesto, Journal of the American Planning Association, 53 (1), pp. 112-120.

-          Kamp,V.I. and Leidelmeijer, K.( 2003): Urban environmental quality and human well-being, Landscape and Urban Planning 65(1):5-18

-          Khasto, M., Saeedi Rezvani, N. (2010): Factors Affecting Urban Lifestyle, Creating a Lively Urban Space with Emphasis on the Concept of the Pawn Shop Center, Urban Identity, 4 (6), pp. 74-6.

-          Kennedy, Rosemary, (2010): Dimensions of livability: a tool for sustainable cities, SB10 Conference held in April in Madrid, Spain

-          Latifi, GH, Jomahpour, M., Grivani, S. (2013): A Comparative Comparison of Urban Living in South Majidieh and Saadatabad Neighborhoods, Urban Management, No. 34, Spring 2014, pp. 40-27.

-          Lopes N. M. and S. Camanho, A. (2012): Public Green Space Use and Consequences on Urban Vitality: An Assessment of European Cities, Social Indicator Research, 1-17.

-          Lynch, K. (1981) A Theory of Good City from, MT Press, Cambridge.

-          Lynch, K. (2006): City image, (M. mozayyani, trans) Tehran: Tehran university publication, 6.

-          Lynch, K. (2011): The Good City Theory, Translated by Hossein Bahraini, Fifth Edition, Tehran University Press

-          Mikail Hachu Soo, G., Azar, AS. (2017): Comparative Study and Evaluation of Urban Living in Private Neighborhoods and Traditional Neighborhoods with a Sustainable Development Approach in Geography: A Case Study of Tabriz Metropolitan Region, Regional Planning Journal, Volume 28, No 1, 284-269.

-          Mortaz M., A., Mansouri, S. A., Javadi, Sh. (2017), “Landscape Approach to Building Valiasr Street Lively with Emphasis on Sample Case Location: Valiasr Street (between Vanak and Parkway Square)”, Bagh Nazar, Fourteenth Year, No. 55, pp. 16-5.

-          Montgomery, J. (1995): Urban vitality and the culture of cities. Planning Practice and Research, 10(2), 101–110.

-          Pakzad, J. (2005): Design Guide for Urban Spaces in Iran, Ministry of Housing and Urban Planning, Deputy of Urban Planning and Architecture.

-          Pakzad, J. (2007): Urban Space Design Guide, Tehran: Shahidi Publications

-          Planning and Consulting Engineers (2010): Master plan of Urmia.

-          Rafiian, M., Piri, A., Yousefi, Z. , Heydari, Q. (2016): A Comparative Comparison of Urban Living in Urban Neighborhoods (Case Study of Kamyaran City), Journal of Paydar City, No. 3

-          Sattari Fard, Sh. (2015): Investigating the Role of Religious Centers in Increasing the Livelyness of Contemporary Cities; Case Study: Imamzadeh Saleh Tajrish Area, Tehran, Urban Management, No. 40, Fall 94, pp. 158-141.

-          Shamseddini, A., Nasibi, S. (1979): The Role and Position of Urban Furniture Layout in the Vitality of Urban Spaces (Case Study: 11 Districts of Shiraz Municipality), Journal of Urban Research and Planning, Vol. 10, No. Consecutive 37, 139 (8), pp. 96-83.

-           Sheikhi, H., Rezaei, MR (2017): "Environmental Quality Assessment of Pedestrian Urban Spaces and Social Responsibility (Case Study: Ferdowsi Street of Ilam"), Journal of Urban Research and Planning, Eighth Year, Issue Twenty-ninth, pp. 98-83.

-          Yaghafuri, H., Kashafi Doost, D. (2018): Evaluation and Evaluation of Right-to-City Components (Case Study: Piranshahr City), Journal of Urban Research and Planning, Volume 9, Issue 35, pp. 68-57.

-          Zeng, Chen, Yan Song, Qingsong He, Feixue Shen, (2018): Spatially explicit assessment on urban vitality: Case studies in Chicago and Wuhan, Sustainable Cities and Society, July 2018, Vol.40, pp.296-306.